Over the course of the 1,214 official at-bats in his career, McCoy has hit .269 in addition to having 327 hits. He has hit a home run 16 times, with 463 total bases and a .072 slugging percentage. McCoy has drawn a free base 190 times while striking out on 122 chances. He has recorded 182 runs and notched 156 runs batted in. His on-base percentage is .369 and he holds a career OPS of .440.
