Consolo has accrued an average at the plate of .221 in his time in baseball with 158 scored runs and an OPS of .415. For his time in the league, he came to bat 1,364 times and has delivered a hit 260 times. He has amassed a slugging percentage of .100 and he has totaled 340 bases. For his career, Consolo has slapped 9 balls over the fence while driving in 83 runs. He has struck out 297 times and has taken a walk on 161 at-bats, which has contributed to a .315 OBP.