Day has an average at the plate of .256 for his career in baseball with 146 runs scored and an OPS of .466. In his time spent in pro baseball, he stepped up to bat 1,289 times and has delivered with a base hit 295 times. His career slugging percentage is .152 and he has accumulated 359 bases. For his MLB career, Day has drilled 8 balls over the fence while driving in 98 runs. He has struck out 141 times and earned a walk on 95 occasions, contributing to a .314 OBP.