Hayes has recorded a batting average of .262 for his time in baseball in addition to 580 scored runs and an OPS of .347. In his time spent in pro baseball, he came to the plate 5,766 times and has delivered a base hit 1,379 times. His career slugging percentage is .031 and he has accumulated 2,094 bases. In his MLB career, Hayes has hit 144 baseballs out of the park while driving in 740 runs. He has been struck out 918 times and earned a walk on 420 at-bats, contributing to a .316 on-base percentage.
