Shay has hit .240 in his time in baseball with 89 scored runs and an OPS of .444. He has struck out 54 times and has taken a walk on 88 occasions, which contributes in part to a .325 on-base percentage. In his MLB career, Shay has hit 2 baseballs over the fence while driving in 62 runs. He has earned a slugging percentage of .119 and he has totaled 228 bases. For his time in baseball, he came to the plate 889 times and has delivered a base hit 186 times.
