Reynolds is sitting with a batting average of .258 for his time in baseball in addition to 640 scored runs and an OPS of .405. He has fanned 417 times and has walked on 480 attempts at the plate, contributing to a .327 on-base percentage. In his MLB career, Reynolds has hit 21 baseballs out of the park while knocking in 353 runs. He has recorded a slugging percentage of .078 and he has a total of 1,632 bases. During his time in professional baseball, he stepped up to bat 5,398 times and has come through with a base hit 1,233 times.