For his professional baseball career, McCarthy has slapped 20 baseballs out of the park while driving in 122 runs. During his time in professional baseball, he came to bat 1,278 times and got on base with a base knock 300 times. He has compiled a slugging percentage of .378 and he has accumulated 430 bases. He has struck out 245 times and earned a walk on 92 occasions, which contributes in part to a .332 OBP. McCarthy has recorded a batting average of .263 in his time in baseball in addition to 169 scored runs and an OPS of .710.
