For the 2,858 official at-bats in his MLB career, McNeil has compiled an average at the plate of .289 and has racked up 827 hits. His on-base percentage is .353 and he also has a career OPS of .784. He has accounted for 391 runs and also has 316 runs batted in. McNeil has tallied a free base 212 times while going down on strikes on 375 tries. He has hit the long ball 69 times, with 1,234 total bases and a .432 slugging percentage.
