McCarthy has an average at the plate of .277 for his career in baseball in addition to 182 runs scored and an OPS of .389. He has struck out 114 times and has gotten a free base on 90 occasions, contributing to a .319 on-base percentage. For his MLB career, McCarthy has slapped 25 balls out of the park while driving in 209 runs. He has earned a slugging percentage of .070 in addition to racking up 611 bases. In his time in the Majors, he came to the plate 1,672 times and has delivered with a base hit 432 times.
