Stahl has recorded a walk 142 times while going down on strikes on 357 chances. His on-base percentage sits at .292 and he has earned a career OPS of .338. He has compiled 167 runs and notched 163 runs batted in. He has hit the long ball 36 times, with 604 total bases and a .046 slugging percentage. For the 1,721 official at-bats in his MLB career, Stahl has compiled an average at the plate of .232 in addition to having 400 base hits.
