For the 1,072 at-bats in his baseball career, Caruso has recorded a batting average of .274 and has racked up 294 hits. He has hit a home run 7 times, with 363 bases in total and a .158 slugging percentage. Caruso has drawn a free base 35 times while striking out on 76 attempts. He has compiled 144 runs in addition to having earned 90 RBIs. His on-base % is .302 and he has earned a lifetime OPS of .460.