For the 7,233 at-bats in his pro career, Peckinpaugh has compiled an average at the plate of .259 with 1,876 hits. His on-base percentage sits at .336 and he has a lifetime OPS of .449. He has scored 1,006 runs and racked up 740 runs batted in. Peckinpaugh has recorded a free base 814 times while fanning on 670 attempts. He has hit the long ball 48 times, as well as 2,426 total bases and a .113 slugging percentage.