Gelof has a batting average of .231 for his career in baseball with 100 runs scored and an OPS of .706. Over the course of his time in the league, he came to bat 847 times and also came through with a hit 177 times. He has amassed a slugging percentage of .412 and he has accumulated 316 bases. In his MLB career, Gelof has hit 31 balls out of the park while driving in 81 runs. He has been struck out 270 times and has walked on 64 occasions, contributing to a .294 OBP.
