In his professional baseball career, Brubaker has hit 22 balls out of the park while knocking in 225 runs. For his time in the league, he faced a pitcher 1,756 times and has delivered a base hit 413 times. He has compiled a slugging percentage of .046 in addition to earning 584 bases. He has fanned 239 times and has taken a walk on 151 occasions, which has contributed to a .333 OBP. Brubaker has compiled an average at the plate of .264 for his baseball career in addition to 208 runs scored and an OPS of .379.