For his professional baseball career, Hafey has drilled 164 baseballs over the fence while driving in 833 runs. Over the course of his pro career, he faced a pitcher 5,116 times and has reached base with a base hit 1,466 times. He has earned a slugging percentage of -.040 and he has racked up 2,433 bases. He has been struck out 477 times and has walked on 372 occasions, which has contributed to a .372 OBP. Hafey has compiled an average at the plate of .317 in his time in baseball with 777 runs scored and an OPS of .332.
