For his pro baseball career, Wagner has hit 15 baseballs out of the park while driving in 228 runs. For his time in the league, he came to bat 2,142 times and has delivered with a hit 458 times. He has amassed a slugging percentage of .064 and he has accumulated 617 bases. He has fanned 152 times and has been walked on 253 occasions, contributing to a .343 on-base percentage. Wagner has recorded a batting average of .248 for his career with 179 scored runs and an OPS of .407.
