Brumfield has drawn a walk 137 times while striking out on 290 attempts. His on-base rate is .318 and he also has a career OPS of .323. He has a total of 260 runs in addition to having earned 162 runs batted in. He has homered 32 times, with 619 bases in total and a .004 slugging percentage. Over the course of the 1,575 official at-bats in his baseball career, Brumfield has hit .257 with 404 base knocks.