For his pro baseball career, Phelps has slapped 54 baseballs over the fence while knocking in 345 runs. For his time in baseball, he faced a pitcher 2,308 times and has come through with a base hit 657 times. His slugging percentage is .013 in addition to racking up 1,000 bases. He has struck out 157 times and has been walked on 160 occasions, which has contributed to a .362 OBP. Phelps has earned a batting average of .310 for his time in baseball with 239 scored runs and an OPS of .376.