Gutteridge has an average at the plate of .256 for his time in baseball with 586 scored runs and an OPS of .362. Over the course of his time in the league, he stepped up to the plate 4,577 times and also came through with a hit 1,075 times. He has earned a slugging percentage of .055 and he has totaled 1,520 bases. In his career, Gutteridge has hit 39 baseballs over the fence while driving in 391 runs. He has struck out 444 times and earned a walk on 309 occasions, contributing to a .308 on-base percentage.