Over the course of the 1,335 at-bats in his professional career, McCarthy has accrued an average at the plate of .229 in addition to 306 base knocks. His OBP is .295 and he also has a career OPS of .420. He has scored 136 runs in addition to having earned 121 RBIs. McCarthy has drawn a free base 104 times while being called out on strikes on 123 tries. He has hit the long ball 5 times, with 377 total bases and a .125 slugging percentage.