McCosky is sitting with a batting average of .312 for his time in baseball with 664 scored runs and an OPS of .493. He has struck out 261 times and has taken a walk on 497 attempts at the plate, which contributes in part to a .386 on-base %. In his professional baseball career, McCosky has drilled 24 balls over the fence while driving in 397 runs. He has earned a slugging percentage of .107 in addition to racking up 1,729 bases. Over the course of his time in the league, he stepped up to bat 4,761 times and also came through with a base hit 1,301 times.
