Gathright has compiled an average at the plate of .263 in his time in baseball in addition to 178 runs scored and an OPS of .500. He has fanned 212 times and has been walked on 97 at-bats, contributing to a .328 OBP. For his MLB career, Gathright has hit 1 baseballs over the fence while driving in 96 runs. His slugging percentage is .172 in addition to having tallied 356 bases. Over the course of his pro career, he approached the plate 1,329 times and has delivered with a hit 309 times.